Showing posts with label federal criminal lawyer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label federal criminal lawyer. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Fort Myers Federal Criminal Lawyer Attorney David A. Brener 239-332-1100 Utilizes Sentencing Poem For Federal Inmate

Recently, Fort Myers based federal criminal defense attorney David A. Brener 239-332-1100 utilized a poem which he wrote in order to persuade a federal district court judge to sentence his client below the advisory federal sentencing guidelines. The client had been charged with conspiracy to possess with intent to distribute oxycodone (roxycodone), methadone, and alprazalam (zanax). "Bank Robbin Bob", the alias used by the defendant and charged in the indictment, had spent almost thirty of his fifty seven years in prison on other charges, and was accused of being part of a scheme in which phony prescriptions were presented to various pharmacies for large quantities of drugs. Brener's client was personally responsible for obtaining over eleven thousand pills, and because the scripts were introduced into evidence, and the client was identified by the pharmacists as the person presenting them, he was convicted after a jury trial. During the trial, the government called numerous cooperating codefendants to testify against the defendant, who had fired a number of prior attorneys and took a very dim view of the court, the prosecutor, and the lead agent. Knowing that the client would insist on adressing the court in an inappropriate and self-defeating manner at sentencing, and being aware that the client had 29 criminal history points and was a career offender, attorney Brener wrote a poem about the case, which he recited at sentencing in an effort to inject some levity and creativity into the proceedings. The Court, which admittedly had other grounds to justify a downward variance, subsequently sentenced the Defendant to seventy (70) months below the low end of the advisory guidelines range, that is, to 135 months instead of the advisory range of 210 to 262 months. The text of the poem follows:

May it please the Court:

• Bank Robin Bob is no angel type – and as you heard at trial he’s really a hype.

• It’s not greed that moves him like some other thugs - for Bank Robbin Bob it’s all about the drugs.

• Yes, he’s got a lot of criminal history points,

• But the motive's always been the pills, H, and joints.

• And it’s true that he did take his case to a trial, but he wasn’t just wastin' the court’s time for a while.

• The case was built on addicts and thieves, and none of those co-defendant’s were worthy of beliefs.

• Every single one of them had a big motive to lie:

• They tried to please the government to get that Rule 35.

• Carey Bergin tried to minimize,

• Her role as one of the masterminds,

• But despite her suit and pleasant smile, the Agent confirmed she lied for a while.

• Susan Hamilton couldn’t reveal, how she ignored her own plea agreement, and took an appeal.

• And Theresa Martinez wouldn’t admit, that she lied for Bob, to help him acquit.

• Jason Bergin had a sham trial, that was over so fast it made Charley Harris smile.

• It was done because Bergin wouldn’t confess, and he wanted to preserve his Motion to Suppress.

• Judge, for almost three hours, the jury was out; I’d started to think, we had reasonable doubt.

• Then come the verdict for conspiracy. The government was happy when they heard it –guilty, guilty, guilty.

• This really isn’t about actual innoce`nce, but assigning culpability that seems to make sense.

• In our system of justice, what we value by far,

• Is the truth of the matter, that is our polestar.

• Each one of the witnesses fell into the muck,
of falsehood –n- self-interest, and began to obstruct.

Bank Robbin Bob forced the government’s proof, but did not commit perjury, or alter the truth.

• Judge, I’m not just asking for mere leniency`.

• But invite you to look at 3553.

• All of the runners got 10 years or less,

• Sprafka even sold drugs,

• To (PROBATION) he confessed.

• For him - the government did not pursue role or the max,

• But agreed to a downward departure in fact.

• Bob is an addict who didn’t sell or buy,

he just took his cut and went to get high.

The fact he’s an addict, he never denied,

• And if you care to know
what happened inside,

• Just look at his childhood, and at his young life,
deprived of love and full of strife.

• If you could go back, with the eyes of a seer,

• You’d say it’s no wonder - the fact that we’re here.

• Unlike the Bergins, who sold pills for cash – Bank Robbin Bob just needed his stash.

• Your Honor, I’m not asking to ignore history,

• Just put it in context, don’t throw away the key.

• Judge I’m not askin' you to send him on home,

• But give me some credit for writing this poem.

Thursday, July 1, 2010

Federal criminal lawyers in Fort Myers

David A. Brener (239-332-1100)has been admitted to the federal courts for over 20 years, and has had numerous federal jury trials. Fort Myers used to be a real small town, with a small number of attorneys, and the number of criminal lawyers who practiced in federal court was even smaller. Today, there are a lot of attorneys, and a growing number who advertise for federal criminal cases in this jurisdiction. While some of these attorneys have a great deal of experience, some of the most aggressive advertisers have never tried a case in federal court, and are not familiar with the practice and procedure, which differs greatly from that in the state courts. Federal court is not only more formal, but requires that almost every request be put in writing, with legal citations. Jury questioning is usually abbreviated, if it is provided at all, and sentencing is extremely complicated and ever changing. Almost every task is more difficult than in state court, and since even a greater percentage of federal cases result in pleas than state cases, some attorneys can practice for years without ever trying a case to a jury in federal court. There is no substitute for actual trial experience, however, and consumers should inquire of prospective attorneys whether they have actually tried cases in the federal courts. For more information, visit our website at www.justiceisourpassion.com

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

David A. Brener Criminal Defense Attorney

Welcome to the Criminal Law Blog of Fort Myers Criminal Defense Attorney
David A. Brener, Esq.
"Over 22 Years Criminal Defense Experience"
Experience DOES Matter

My Passions are:
The U.S. Constitution
The Florida Constitution
The 1st, 4th, 5th, 6th & 8th Amendments
"Defending the accused, especially in tough cases"
Defending Capital Cases
Motorcycle Riding
Rock, Blues, and Jazz

David A. Brener, Esq. has been a member of the Florida Bar since 1988, the Federal Bar since 1989, and the Federal Trial Bar (Southern District)since 1992. He is a member of the Bar of the Supreme Court of the United States, and the Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit.

David Brener has the highest peer review rating of "AV Preeminent" in criminal law by Martindale Hubbell. He is in the Bar Registry of Preeminent Attorneys. David Brener is the current Chairperson of the Criminal Law Practice Section of the Lee County Bar, President of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, Lee County Chapter, and the only Lee County attorney on the Registry for Capital Death Penalty Cases and the Commission on Capital Cases. In addition, he is a long- standing member of the the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.

In twenty-two (22) years as a criminal defense lawyer, he has handled many thousands of criminal cases, including the trial of hundreds of cases through verdict, as well as:
  • negotiated thousands of favorable plea bargains on behalf of clients with prosecutors in Lee County and the Twentieth Circuit (Naples, Punta Gorda, LaBelle);
  • personally handled approximately fifty (55) homicide cases;
  • acted as lead defense counsel or co-counsel in nineteen (19) capital first degree murder cases where the death penalty was sought;
  • has no clients on death row.
  • handled and tried cases to juries in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, Lee, Collier, and Charlotte Counties;
  • had numerous trials of federal criminal cases, including in the District Court for the Middle District of Florida.

Over his career as a criminal defense lawyer, Brener has written and been published in various criminal defense magazines, including:

"Re-thinking Change of Venue in High Profile Capital Cases", published in "The Champion"
Magazine, a publication of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (June 2010);

“Prosecutorial Misconduct in the Penalty Phase closing Argument of Capital Case" published in "Florida Defender", Magazine of the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (Winter 2007);

“Thoughts on Delays in Death Sentences,” Guest Opinion, Fort Myers News-Press (January 10, 2008);

“The Mitigation Specialist as an Integral Part of the Defense Team in a Capital Murder Case,” Res Gestae, Lee County Bar Magazine (November 2008);

“Limitations on the Scope of Voir Dire,” Res Gestae (January 2009);

“The Bottom Line, Death Penalty Costly” Res Gestae (February 2009);

“The Necessity for a Special Jury Instruction on Heat of Passion Manslaughter,” Res Gestae (March 2009);

“Death Penalty Costly in Tough Economic Times,” Guest Opinion, Fort Myers News-Press (April 02, 2009);

“Florida’s Death Penalty Problems and Recommendations,” Res Gestae (May 2009);

"Arraignment Exception Swallows Rule" ; Res Gestae (August,2009);

"On Jury Nullification," Res Gestae (October 2009);

"Not Just Wishful Thinking", The American Bar Association Guidelines for the Appointment and Performance of Defense Counsel in Death Penalty Cases," Res Gestae, (January 2010);

"It's All Junk: Defense Counsel's Duty to Litigate Forensic Evidence", Res Gestae, (May, 2010)

"Lawyers Must Be "Capital Qualified" to Represent First Degree Murder Clients Unless the Death Penalty Has Been Waived", Res Gestae, (July/August 2010).

"The Credibility of Forensic Evidence", Res Gestae, September 2010;

"Life is Worth the Wait: Supreme Court Reverses Death Sentences", to be published, November 2010.

Mr. Brener has appeared on "In Session" (formerly Court TV) as a special local commentator, and has been quoted in:

  • The New York Times
  • The Washington Post
  • The Miami Herald
  • The Naples Daily News
  • The Fort Myers News-Press
  • ESPN
  • The Cape Coral Daily Breeze
  • The Fort Lauderdale Sun Sentinel
David Brener served as lead defense counsel on a wide variety of criminal cases that were brought to trial, including cases where the charges were:
  • FIRST DEGREE MURDER
  • SECOND DEGREE MURDER
  • DRUG TRAFFICKING
  • SEXUAL BATTERY (RAPE)
  • AGGRAVATED ASSAULT AND BATTERY WITH FIREARM / DEADLY WEAPON
  • ARMED AND UNARMED ROBBERY
  • ARMED AND UNARMED BURGLARY
  • GRAND THEFT AND DEALING IN STOLEN PROPERTY
  • POSSESSION AND USE OF FIREARMS AND WEAPONS
  • DRUG SALES, DELIVERIES, PURCHASES, AND POSSESSIONS
  • CARJACKING
  • HOME / BOAT INVASION ROBBERY
  • MANSLAUGHTER
  • ATTEMPTED MURDER
  • CONSPIRACY
  • KIDNAPPING
  • POSSESSION OF NARCOTICS WITH INTENT TO DISTRIBUTE
  • ARSON
  • FALSE IMPRISONMENT
  • RESISTING ARREST
  • DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
  • CULTIVATION AND MANUFACTURE OF ILLEGAL DRUGS
  • BATTERY ON LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER
  • FLEEING AND ELUDING
  • LEWD ASSAULT, BATTERY AND MOLESTATION
  • DUI
  • MISDEMEANORS
  • ECONOMIC / WHITE COLLAR CRIMES
Call 239-332-1100 to set up an appointment. The initial consultation is free, and we have flexible appointments.
Thank you.